What is a 401(k) hardship withdrawal & is it a good idea?

A 401(k) hardship withdrawal can feel like a lifeline when the unexpected arises or financial pressures grow too great. However, tapping your nest egg early has its pros and cons. On the one hand, you'll have a solution to your immediate needs. On the other hand, there’s the possibility of jeopardizing long-term financial security. 

‍

So, when does an early withdrawal from a 401(k) make sense? In this post, we'll discuss 401(k) hardship withdrawals, the repercussions of a false claim, and alternative solutions to consider based on your needs.

What is a 401(k) hardship withdrawal?

A 401(k) hardship withdrawal allows you to tap into your retirement savings, typically without a penalty, but only in the event of "immediate and heavy financial need." Unlike a 401(K) loan, which lets you borrow and pay yourself back over time, you're not on the hook for repayment. Although the penalties are generally waived, you’ll still have to pay taxes on the amount taken. 

401(k) hardship withdrawal reasons and eligibility 

Firstly, you'll need a 401(k) plan that permits early withdrawals to qualify. 

‍

Additionally, you’ll need to satisfy the IRS’s definition of financial hardship. The IRS specifies you can withdraw funds for yourself, your spouse, or beneficiary for the following: 

• Expenses to prevent foreclosure or eviction
• Repair costs for damage to your principal residence (in the event of losses from floods, fires, or earthquakes)
• Medical bills not covered by insurance 
• Funeral or burial costs 
• Tuition, fees, and other education-related expenses 
• Home buying costs associated with purchasing a primary residence 

Applying for a 401(K) hardship withdrawal

The IRS may oversee rules around hardship withdrawals, but guidelines and approval ultimately come from your specific plan sponsor. 

‍

To get started, contact an HR representative at your company or your plan administrator. Once you determine the account provider's rules around eligibility, you can typically submit a withdrawal application in person or online. 

‍

A plan sponsor or employer can ask for proof of the hardship. To avoid delays or denial, have the proper documentation ready to substantiate your claim. This can include medical bills, purchase agreements, eviction or foreclosure notices, funeral invoices, education bills, or repair estimates. 

401(k) hardship withdrawals limits

The maximum allowable amount varies and is determined by the 401 (k) account administrator. Generally, you can only withdraw enough to resolve the hardship as well as cover taxes and penalties.   

What are the disadvantages of a 401(k) hardship withdrawals?

Most financial advisors recommend treating your retirement fund as a last resort rather than a piggy bank when you need cash. With good reason, since chipping away at your account can have the following impact: 

• Retirement growth: You could miss years of investment growth, significantly diminishing your nest egg.
• Taxes and penalties: Withdrawing for foreclosure, funeral, education, or home-buying expenses will still result in the standard 10% withdrawal penalty if you are under the age of 59 1/2 years. Additionally, you’ll have to pay taxes on what you withdraw. 
• Long-term consequences: If you can’t catch up on your retirement savings, you'll likely be in a financially vulnerable spot come retirement. As a result, you may be forced to take on debt, work longer than planned, or alter your lifestyle in your golden years. 

‍

Before proceeding with a hardship withdrawal, it's best to consult a financial advisor and explore alternative solutions. 

What happens if you lie about hardship withdrawal eligibility?

When your back is against the wall, tapping into a cash reserve you already have feels like a no-brainer — even if you don't meet the requirements. However, lying to get 401k hardship withdrawal relief can have severe implications. 

‍

The consequences of false hardship withdrawal can range from fines and penalties to tax implications or even jail time. 

‍

Additionally, lying to an employer can severely hinder your career growth or result in job loss. In other words, if you don’t qualify, seek an alternative solution. 

401(k) hardship withdrawals: alternatives to consider

401(k) loan

In lieu of a hardship withdrawal from a 401k account, you can explore a 401(k) loan. The loan allows you to borrow from your retirement account penalty-free. You repay the loan over a five-year term through standard payroll deductions.

‍

Like a hardship withdrawal, failing to make catch-up contributions could result in a serious financial shortfall come retirement. Consider consulting a financial advisor to determine whether this makes sense for your needs.

0% APR credit cards and low-interest personal loans

If your financial needs aren’t too great, consider a low-interest credit card or personal loan, which can be more cost-effective than depleting your account. Since credit cards and personal loans have no restrictions on how they can be used, you can address any financial needs.

‍

Depending on what you need cash for, you may be able to find a provider that offers unique terms or competitive rates specific to your cause. For example, a particular medical loan lender might offer better terms for paying medical expenses than a credit union. So, before applying, shop around to find the best terms.

Forbearance solutions

Dealing with a delinquent mortgage is challenging. If this is your current situation, exploring other solutions is still best before drawing from your 401(k). 

‍

Start by communicating with your lender, who can provide options to remain in good standing or prevent foreclosure. A lender may offer the following:

• Mortgage repayment plan: Working with a lender, you can agree on a schedule to catch up on missed payments. 
• Loan modification: Your lender can permanently change your loan terms, helping with monthly payment affordability.  
• Forbearance: You can ask your lender to suspend your monthly payments for a designated time.   

Home equity

Home equity financing often offers more competitive rates than other debt products. Additionally, there are no restrictions on what equity financing can cover, which means you're free to use it for whatever you need to. 

‍

Equity tools to explore include: 

• Home equity loan: A home equity loan allows you to access a lump sum of cash from your home's wealth. You'll make fixed monthly payments over a 5-30 year term. 
• Home equity line of credit (HELOC): A HELOC offers a revolving credit line that can be tapped anytime during the draw period, typically ten years. HELOCs have variable rates, which means monthly payments fluctuate based on market conditions. 
• Home equity investment (HEI): An HEI allows you to access a lump sum of cash in exchange for a share of your home's future appreciation. There are no monthly payments. Instead, homeowners pay back their investment anytime during a 30-year term, penalty-free. Unlike traditional equity financing options, there are no income requirements or need for perfect credit. 

Frequently asked questions

What proof do you need for a hardship withdrawal?

To qualify for a hardship withdrawal, you’ll need to provide documentation that verifies the nature and urgency of your financial need. This can include repair estimates or invoices for home repairs, medical bills, eviction or foreclosure notices, or tuition bills, depending on the situation.

What home repairs qualify for hardship withdrawal?

Home repairs that qualify for a hardship withdrawal typically address significant damage or conditions that impact the safety or livability of your home. Examples include repairs due to natural disasters like floods or hurricanes, fixing structural issues such as a damaged roof or foundation, addressing health and safety hazards like mold or asbestos, repairing critical systems like plumbing or heating, or making repairs required to meet building codes.

Can I take out a hardship withdrawal from my 401k to pay off debt?

Paying off debt with a 401(k) account generally does not qualify for a hardship withdrawal. However, you may be able to pay down debt using a 401(k) loan.

‍

The bottom line

Whether you're facing emergency home repairs or an unexpected loss, it can be tempting to tap into your 401(k) account. However, before taking a hardship distribution, explore alternative solutions and carefully weigh the short-term relief with the long-term effects.

‍

Find relief and safeguard your future financial well-being with a Home Equity Investment from Point. Prequalify today, with no impact on your credit.